One of the great things about our federalist system of government is that each of the states can act as a laboratory for public policy ideas. The rest of us have the opportunity to watch and learn from the varying degrees of success and failure of the other 49 states and decide if we would like to apply any of these policies to our own community, state, or to the country as a whole.
In recent years, New York and California have given us case studies in the results of a “tax the rich” policy. New York has seen a mass exodus of rich people. The result has been shrinking tax revenues and fewer jobs. These rich people we love to hate are also job creators. They own small businesses or portions of large businesses. These businesses we love to hate also have the distinction of being where people work and get paychecks. California has given us the extra blessing of seeing what a dual strategy of raising taxes on rich people and increasing regulations on business can produce. The result: impending bankruptcy. California has seen businesses, both large and small, run like Secretariat to states like Idaho, Tennessee, and Texas. The shrinking tax base means that the government doesn’t have any “makers” left to pay for all the “takers” the welfare state has encouraged. Most recently, California has been trying to convince its citizens that the mandatory, zero-interest ”loan” it will be taking from their paychecks isn’t really a tax.
Those of us in the so-called “fly over” states should be left wondering: with these outstanding examples of failure on both coasts, why would Washington want to pursue the same failing policies for the whole nation? And yet, what do we hear from the President, Speaker Pelosi and the others? The same nonsensical policies that has failed New York and caused its liberal governor to tell his fellow Democrats to please leave the rich people alone. The same nonsensical policies that have failed California twice in the past decade (remember Gov. Grey Davis?). If you see the guy next to you in the lab burn himself, do you check his notes and then repeat the same process? Apparently Washington says yes.